I listened to the mp3 version through a pair of Mackie HR824's...

What are you listening through?

Have a listen to 'Jump'. Not exactly bone dry, that one!

Rock music tends towards the 'bigger' sounds, in general. Maybe trying to suggest the 'stadium' sound, I'm not sure. But the drums? I don't think I've heard THAT dry on a rock track ever... You don't have to use a hall preset, but it needs a LOT more 'room'. They sound like they were tracked in a closet (sorry!). Think Bonham... Think Def Leppard... Think Van Halen... Big rooms around the drums during tracking, then some larger stuff put around the snare and tomes afterwards.

Yes, it's easy to overdo reverb. It's also possible (though rarer!) to underdo it, too...