Thank you Dave for your beautiful reply. I have a real point to make but its getting lost in it all. I wish to have a careing relationship with you a second at a time -- I had a hope in it all that we could look dispasionately at some songs -- I perhaps should have overlooked for ever and ever amen as it is indeed a lovely song (But). I sing some trash. I do not wish to try and make my point any further. I want you to know however that when I said I,d like a list of good songs it was with faith in your ability to help - I really hope you didnt think I was saying your chioces are bad. I was also hoping to look at a few issues in some of the "good songs" --anyway I am really glad of your efforts. You mention our responsibilities and I agree so perhaps when we have more time we could jointly look at some of them. Hopeing that our relationship lasts for ever and ever amen best wishes Pierce.