Quote:
Originally posted by cgiles:
Whenever I encounter someone who is convinced that only his answer or response is the correct one, especially in situations that offer many possible responses, I tend to discount anything this person has to say (even when there is some value there).

Hi,
I haven't read such opinions you talk about in this thread so far. Why do you say this?
People have the right to have and express opinions especially in situations that offer many possible responses.
As a listener I can judge the result one achieve using either metod. Voncken's interpretation of baroque music may appeal to the home users who can't play well but you might agree that it sounds very primitive when such music is played like this.
In other cases doing a sequence makes is useless because a style perfectly fits the music.
And nowadays there are arrangers with recording capabilities, so one can combine the both methods.
Best regards,
George V