Originally Posted By Uncle Dave
Musicianship can certainly be entertaining, on it's own, but I'm guessing the OP was referring to the OMB approach, where the audience benefits from a little "nudge" from an EmmCee. Most large scale concerts are all about hype - there's pyrotechnics, extensive lighting, smoke, and video .... all that adds to the entertainment value, but (once again) if you're talking more serious listening environments (jazz, classical), the audience probably doesn't expect too much of a "showman."

I pride myself on being a showman, who's constantly trying to improve my musicianship. They go hand in hand, for me. I have some people fooled into thinking I can even play jazz, although, I won't dare put myself in that category. I have a jazz "feel", but lack serious, trained chops. There are nights when I desperately need to showcase some technique, if only for a song or two. Last night, for example, I played my tenor for 1/2 of the first set, and interspersed it throughout the night, whenever I could. It gave me a more "legit" element to an otherwise sterile (digital) performance. Even with all the improvements that modern keyboards offer, there's still something special about adding an acoustic element to a digital performance. (guitar, sax, even a tambourine helps make it sound more believable) I'll be tantalizing my crowds all month with guitar, bass, uke, mandolin, clarinet, sax, flute, and creative Manhattan Transfer-ish harmonies behind our many guest singers. I see my stage as a mini showcase each night, and the balance between music and schmaltz is adjusted as needed. Every night is different.



Excellent post. Lotta good stuff in there; read it twice. I like that it doesn't try to push one side over another, but merely explains HIS approach to the balance between showmanship and musicianship (and there always IS a balance). It's great to have the skills on both sides of the equation to make those adjustments (as UD does), but if you consider yourself a MUSICAL entertainer and you're really weak in the MUSICAL side of it, all the ENTERTAINING skills in the world are not going to hide it. For pure 'musicians', the music IS the entertainment. Dave's example of 'jazz' and 'classical' illustrates that very nicely. Everything has value; it depends on what the audience is there for.

chas
_________________________
"Faith means not wanting to know what is true." [Nietzsche]