After very careful listening to the guitar techniques in both recordings, in my mind they are identical. I even picked out very distinctive playing nuances and sure enough they matched in both versions. As a guitar player myself I find it impossible to believe anyone could so accurately copy Chet Atkins version of the song on a keyboard. And if it was a accurate note for note copy of these 2 guitarists I would certainly mention that I had copied their version when I posted the track for listening because I'd be so proud of the undertaking.

There really is nothing more to be said here.