Maybe this is a discussion for The Bar, I don't know. I have heard some performances here, recently and in the past, that were nothing short of atrocious, and would be pointed out as such on practically every music board on the 'net EXCEPT THIS ONE where they garnered 100% praise and 'attaboys' . I think it's because this board has cultivated a very warm and close-knit community who would rather lie (or even die) rather than risk damaging the fragile ego of some long-standing, self-proclaimed 'master' keyboardist, member. This is especially true if that member has a history of being very helpful and a solid contributor in OTHER ways. I think the other (sort of legitimate) reason is a fear of discouraging other non-professional players from posting their music (not good!), which is at least one good reason for having a forum such as this.

So, what's the best course of action? Do we adopt a policy of "if you can't say something nice, don't say anything", OR, in the hopes of helping someone by giving them an honest evaluation and critique, you 'TELL IT LIKE IT IS', albeit in a supportive and respectful manner. It's tough telling a old, experienced, but totally talent-less player, how to improve when you know down in your heart he CAN'T, or WON'T (mainly because he doesn't believe you and feels pretty secure about his skills). Whew! Tough choice. What do you think?

chas