Originally posted by squeak_D:
Bill.., if Scott had said to my face (either directly or indirectly) his response here to Donny regarding judging the timing on a song I've never heard before...., he would certainly get a colorful response from me....
Donny points out timing issues with the harmonies (that even Beaky agreed with) then Scott harps Donny for pointing out timing issues in a song he has never heard. Yeah.., that's an asshole thing to say IMO. Since when does having to know a song first become a prerequisite to determining as to whether or not there are timing issues...???
I still say some of you guys need to do a few more push ups every day and toughen up a little more.., and stop being so damn thin skinned.
Donny gives an honest opinion about something that even the poster then confirmed.., yet it's not the POSTER that harps Donny. Another member insults Donny's most basic ability to judge timing. Yeah.., that's insulting. Perhaps Scott should read between his own lines
[This message has been edited by squeak_D (edited 05-03-2009).]
There wasn't anything wrong with what Donny or Scott said. Donny felt the timing was off, Scott allowed that maybe, it was intentionally done that way per Larry's choice.
Both are reasonable ways to address that part of the tune.
This crap about pushups and toughening up? Are you serious? What do you know about Scott? Anything? Who the hell are you to talk to anyone on this forum like that, let alone a guy like Scott?
He disagreed with Donny. So what? Scott's posted his work on the forum several times. There was criticism and he didn't crap his pants about it.
Once again, let's not strain ourselves wondering why good quality contributors and forum members leave and don't return.
Class act, pal...
------------------
Bill in Dayton
Previous Topic
Index
