Originally posted by Synthman:
Hi again
Hey guys. Don't you read what I write before you hurry to the keyboard and answear the topics?????
My hole intension with my topics is to clear up: What do we do, if no style companies sees a business in making styles and midifiles. I think it's only maybe 5% of the users of arranger keyboards who's capable to make there own styles or midifiles from scratch.
This is the issue in this discussion.
And further more there is the discussion of copyrights.
I see it straight from a performers viewpoint.
Regards
Synthman
That's a "hole intention" alright - you can't limit this question to something that simple-minded I'm afraid. A "performer's viewpoint" is hardly what determines whether copyrights are at the heart of this topic or not - they are, period.
Ever seen one of those "50,000 MIDI files on one CD for $25" on the web? They were scabbed off of the alt.binaries.music.midi newsgroup years ago when people used that forum for exchanging midi files. I happen to be very good at making midi files and I used to post a few now and then for others to use and enjoy... I was hopeful of even selling some of them someday... but this ripoff changed that. Once I checked and found out I couldn't copyright arrangements in the US, which is what my midi files are, I realized that my hard work would simply be resold by people who put no actual effort into the content and would likely sell my work for cheaper than I could.
Of course this is strictly from a MIDI file producer's point of view, which you may or may not share, but it does affect why you can't get MIDI files as easily as you may like as a performer: copyrights have their limitations and I can't afford a fleet of lawyers.