Hello Scott,

If I were you I'd buy a Yamaha pedal,
I just looked at it but there is no reference number on it.
The Boss pedal (unlatched) is very small to hit on with your foot while at the Yamaha the pedal is at whole surface.
I have been using mine over 1'000 gigs so reliability is great.
This pedal is all metal with Rubber at the upper and lower side.
This is very nice beacause if you're standing at a tiled floor the pedal won't slide as much as others do.
Before these pedals I also used cheap models but these are indeed worthless for pro's like you.
One very very important question is if you're standing or sitting during performing.
Sitting: no problem to use 3 pedals.
Standing: DON'T USE 3 PEDALS!!!
Why? You're standing unbalanced, it's very bad for your back.
Abouth the other pedals, IMO i just use a damper pedal only, most of the time you have time to press buttons instead of using 3 pedals. It's better to have 1 moment during a gig that you're a little late pressing the vocalizer switch or fill rather then getting confused abouth using which pedal (especially at a tiled floor).
Hope this helps.

René