An arrangement by ANY artist is subjective, several examples are:

Mr. Frank Sinatra recorded “The way you look tonight” in a Foxtrot/Swingy feel.
The same song was recorded recently by Michael Buble in a Bossanova style, also Steve Tyrell made another version also different, and that those not make it “wrong or BAD approach”, another examples are, Dean Martin, Harry Connick, Jr. and Michael Buble made a recording of Sway, 3 very creative distinct approaches to the same song, the song Moonglow by Rod Stuard , Carly Simon and Steve Tyrell, have different orchestrations, also artist like Peter Cincotti with the contemporary singers I mention earlier, are making MANY recordings that where made popular by Sammy Davis, Nat King Cole, etc……There are hundreds of examples, like New York New York by Liza Minelli and Frank Sinatra, etc.

Because someone recorded earlier a song DOES NOT HAVE to be the SAME carbon copy arrangement/orchestration for someone else.

My point is, you can arrange/play/sing a song with an entire different approach and that does not make it wrong, bad…..simply, is different.
And for those who proclaim to be “brutally honest”, you can be honest with INTEGRITY, without been crude/rude, need to have more class and demonstrate education and RESPECT, or, that does not mean nothing?

You can express your opinion and be objective with a language non abusive/aggressive. Even if English is not your native language, like it is in my case, so, it is not excuse to use demeaning language, I wonder if those who are quick to bash somebody else’s work, same members who NEVER post ANYTHING musical or make a significant POSITIVE contribution, I start doubting if some of them can really play/perform?, because OWNING an instrument like the arrangers or workstations, does not make them professional performers.
The conduct by some of this members makes a deterrant for members WHO CAN contribute POSITIVE knowledge, music, tips, etc.

This is most likely to be my last post at least for some time.
Please, be respectful.