I think an audience would prefer the best musical offering you can provide as opposed to being pandered to with half-hearted crowd-pleasers.
chas
Chas, thanks for your kind words, and I know you're not trying to ruffle my feathers, but I had to highlight the above line. I never offer a half-hearted "anything" ... my gear, my attitude, and my preparation are given my full heart ... and soul, and sweat. I work on my musicianship more than my showmanship, because it needs more work. My bravado comes naturally, and needs to be kept in check. (Wish I had my Dad's tact) I believe humility on stage is paramount to audience appreciation, so I'm always aware of it, and constantly trying to improve.
It's true that most audiences go to a music venue to hear a good product, and watch its creation, but most people are not schooled musicians, and as such, they don't know exactly what to expect. If they see an act who smiles (Whitney?) , and gets immersed in a performance, they will probably enjoy it more than a scowling, twisted face, or someone's back (Jim Morrison?) because they can identify with it. That's why people respond to singers, and lyrics. We all love a good story, right?
It all comes down to ticket sales, and filling seats. I sure hope my bar stools keep getting filled, because I'm not ready for a new career at my age.
Thanks for the intelligent debate, and the chance to share some of my strongest thoughts on a subject that's very close to my heart. Let's keep the positive talk going.