Looks like there are two specific camps here...one small group of "purists" who try to keep use of MP3's and the like at a minimum and a probably larger group of people who think that the right thing to do is use "every trick in the book". Most of us fall somewhere in the middle.

The "right" way is to do what's right for you as a player. Problem is, the "use anything" people are always defending their approach, and the "purists" (me, included) come across as "elitists" who are implying that the other camp is substituting tricks for talent.

And, as always, there's that nagging difference between musicians and entertainers. Basically, the two sides don't like each other much.

I'll tell you that after my recent injury to my left hand and arm I wouldn't be playing much without an arranger. Serves me right for all the times I knocked them and talked about my "love-hate" relationship with them.

Donny and I are about as different as two people can be. That doesn't mean that we wouldn't enjoy a cup of coffee together or even listen to each other play. It just probably wouldn't work for us to play together.

I have my opinions about music and how it should be played, and I'm probably not going to change that or my opinion about some styles of music, kinds of equipment, "chicken hats" and the like.

But I'll be the first one to respect Donnys' right to his beliefs and way of approaching things.

Chas and I are "joined at the hip" on most matters...politics...music, etc. Frankly, it bothers me when his opinions are met with bitter, negative responses. And we would be completely compatible on the bandstand.

What's wrong with stating opinions in a respectful way and leaving it at that?


Russ

PS: (Come on you folks, you KNOW I'm ALWAYS RIGHT!) LOL!