No, on the contrary, Beaky... I think this is EXACTLY what this forum should be about, rather than the endless pissing contests. Using an arranger to make MUSIC, rather than for it's technical specs is what we should all be about.

Sadly, little of this gets discussed. I am always FAR more interested in WHAT music anyone makes, than WHICH arranger they make it on, but it seems few share this viewpoint.

And 'hypercritical'? I try to think not... I just tend to take and give it based on higher expectations than local club or NH level. What passes for acceptable here at SZ (or if critiqued at a higher level, gets accused of 'slamming') isn't necessarily good enough to go to the next level, let alone the top...

Remain 'hypercritical', remain skeptical about flattery, and at least you keep a realistic viewpoint about your chances! Don't give up the dream, but keep your eyes wide open