I've seen Willow Weep For Me done in the key of G with the second chord of the first measure being D+ and also C7. This is so in many different versions.

The D+ is used in Vol 2 of the original bootleg version of Standards from the late 40's.

The C7 is used in Real Book 2. Of course both of these books are notorious for wrong chords.

Both chords give a different flavor. I favor D+ unless I want to do it more bluesy.

I have also considered that the notes of both chords could be put together to create a C9(b5) or a C(#11).

Here's a version using the augmented chord:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFsY3HMTpoQ

Here's a version using the IV7 chord:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gHmbzvGIPtk

Better versions out there, but these clearly show the two versions.

Either way a great tune.

What do you use and why? If you don't play the song, which one sounds better and why?

The two other recordings were just picked because they showed the two ways to do that particular chord.

Here is a recording using the IV7 chord using vibes as the main solo instrument which is the way I've always heard it in my head. I tend to play it along these lines except I've always used the V+ chord.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NEfIuaP176k

Scott ... why not post YOUR version(s) ?

I'd love to hear that myself.

For sure. I'll do it in my spare time

Funny, that is the type of answer I expected first and no actual response to the question yet.haha, hey it's SZ

Actually I like the traditional Army answer to that suggestion which is, of course, "that's a good idea, go ahead and do it yourself."

I guess you still want opinions..

In your example..key of G...the second chord I use a Bb5b,7/Ab....

The "why" is harder to answer...I like the Ab in the bass movement, and the flat fith is actually the melody note.....it just works for me..

Ahhh, arranger chord display screens...such a difference they make!

Dennis, I play the song and report my findings....