Alan, they are still there, every one of them. While everyone acknowledges your musical and technical skills, I think some of your comments were anything but constructive criticism, and in fact, some seemed hurtful toward the OP. I don't expect anyone to be politically correct when it comes to posting comments on another's musical submissions, however, there needs to be a degree of discretion when making any comments, positive or negative. I can readily see Roger's point of view, particularly in the post you made pertaining to a song Torben and his female vocalist. Torben, who is an extremely talented musician, has been on the PSR Tutorial forum for many years, he has contributed a lot outstanding creations to that segment of the forum and has offered technical assistance to many over those years. In that particular post, you had nothing constructive to say, no real advice that would improve the submission, just some nasty comments a few missing passing chords, and his vocalist talent that were uncalled for. Though I didn't take time to read all your posts, there apparently were several similar incidents that caused Roger to take the action he took.

Good luck,

Gary