Guess what Tim. You can currently get a great deal on a Roland Fantom "X"8 that has both 128 note polyphony and an Aftertouch feature and it's a WHOLE lot easier to navigate and use than the Yamaha Motif series. I would say get the Fantom "G"8 because you'd be getting the latest/greatest technology and sound plus same ease of use factor, but your church may not want to spend that much on a replacement keyboard which is quite understandable, especially in these dire economic times we are currently experiencing in the U.S. and worldwide. Although maybe you can get a rich parishioner to pony up the extra sum perhaps?? Just let your members know there is a 'real' need for a new, easier to use keyboard, and you might be pleasantly surprised that one of the members steps up to the plate to actually fill that "extra" need.

All the best,
Mike

PS: I'm still searching...