Motif Es player here as well. Ed is spot on too. They are all good. For me it came down to what I liked best in acoustic type sounds and then some of the features.

After trying them all, I've decided I still prefer the ES, but I wouldn't be unhappy about owning either the Triton Extreme or the Fantom.

If I was choosing a sample based board mainly on internal synth type sounds, I think I'd likely lean toward the Triton a little more, but I have more than enough Analog, digital and hybrid softsynths and modules that can be tweaked much deeper than what a workstation can give me, so personally I am not interested much in workstation synth sounds.

AJ