.
In another thread, I stated that the arranger keyboards that come with song tutorials, light-up keys, etc. were inferior teaching tools. I stated that instructional computer software would be a much better choice for the new player.

Actually, I am no expert. I only really know the products of PG music very well, and I love them.

I wonder if anyone here has experience in both areas. Have you tried "teaching keyboards" as well as piano learning software? Have you used them as a student, or a teacher? I would like to hear your informed opinion of which works best. Also, is there a teaching method specifically for arranger keyboards?

.