Quote:
Originally posted by Uncle Dave:
Am I missing something here?
Do you think the general uninformed public thinks that using a sequence means that you DON'T play?
In a live band ... you only get to play YOUR part. With a sequence .... you still get to play YOUR part. At least - that's the approach I take. If I use a sequenced backing - I am the piano player. Remember that guy? Playing piano over a band or a sequence is the same technique .... only the band usually screws up the timing and some of the notes. Give me a perfect sequence over a mediocre band ANYday.


AMEN, UD! I have successfully made the transition, and use my PSR3000 with my "live" 5 piece band, using midi files.

Uncle Dave is right. I AM still playing the piano parts, and have found a drummer who, because of his vocal strength, can spice up the existing drum track, and plays along live with the track. (No different than having two drummers ala Doobie Brothers). Very rare to find a drummer who puts the overall sound of the band before any personal ego. I also remove any bass, and all solos (I use a live sax player!), leaving rhythmic guitars and orchestra-type parts in for full effect. A lot of work manipulating the midis, but the end result is well worth the effort, believe me!

The results:

1) The perfect (in my opinion) blend of midi and live performace, where things like cymbals and hi-hats are heard as a live element, and compliment to the drum tracks. We have four vocalists who can sing lead at any given time, and blend well harmonically.

2) In only three months of actually performing together, we have already secured twenty weddings this year alone, as well as many club and restaurant dates.

3) Start-up time is minimal when using midi files, and easier to learn material.


Now, don't get me wrong. We are also capable of playing songs 100% live when we need to, (i.e. special requests, etc.). But, that's the beauty of it all! It's never the same two nights in a row, and we still need to be sharp, and musically sound!


Just my opinion.....

Angelo


[This message has been edited by cam8neel (edited 03-22-2005).]