Quote:
Originally posted by Scottyee:
Manuel, though I understand how this features will assist less than adequate keyboard players in giving the audience the impression (albeit false) that they're more skilled players than they really are, I find this kind of shortcut adds yet another 'nail in the coffin' to whatever respect & appreciation TRULY skilled musicians get. This performance assistance feature only cheapens music performance to the level of pressing buttons & keys (and ANY to boot)

Ok,some here suggest that music is all about entertainment. I can't DISAGREE more. Though entertainment is a factor, to me, music is a an expressive art form. Luckily, my audiences still want to hear ME actually sing & play the keyboard LIVE. Is musical performance in some circles now turning into just some kind of grand illusion of flash, glitz and smoke & mirrors? There IS a difference between a karaoke singer, DJ, and a 100% live performance musician. I just hope general audiences still appreciate the difference 5 years from now. This biz is looking more and more about JUST PRETENDING to be actually playing (creating) music with little or no keyboard musicianship required.

Scott, I could not dissagree more. It's show biz. Granted, your audiences may have come to see and hear you perform, but most of all, they want to be entertained. And, anything that enhances that entertainment is just another tool in the entertainment toolbox of OMB entertainers. That enhancement device is nothing more and nothing less. It's not faking anything--it's just another tool, the same as the keyboard, it's internal styles, it's magnificant voices, mega-voices, layers, etc...--they're all tools that should be used to their fullest extent. Anyone that does not use these, and any of the other fantastic, technoligal advancements now availbe to OMB performers is cheating not only themselves, but their audiences as well.

Manuel, my aplogies for ranting, but this one really hit me hard. Also, please be assured that my attack was not at you whatsoever, but at the direction that music keyboard performance seems to be heading. The Yamaha Performance Assistance feature in my opinion is really a double edged sword.

Perhaps I've just over-reacted. Anyway, it'll be interesting to get some perspective from others on this.

Scott


Three decades ago I played a lead guitar with a drum machine, a mixer, and a lousy PA system. I was considered a maverick because I chose to utilize a drum machine and not use a drummer who couln't stay sober enough to keep time. And whan that first keyboard became availale, one that was not much more than a drum machine with a piano, it changed the entertainment business dramatically. Today's arranger keyboards are beyond anything this old man could have imagined way back then. They've come a long, long way, and as time goes on, they will ultimately advance. These advancements do not detract from one's musical ability, but instead, they enhance it by providing musicians with tools that unleash their creative juices and allow them to freely flow. I have always wished I had the talent and ability to master complex chords, read music, and perform songs that written by the masters. Unfortunately, that never happened. Instead, I have become an entertainer--not a musician. Though I would like to be both, this is not the case. Therefore, I like many of my fellow entertainers, will continue to utilize tools such as internal style files, internal voices, midi files and yes, even the performance assistant--anything that keeps the audiences entertained. That's why they came to see and hear me.

Cheers,

Gary
_________________________
PSR-S950, TC Helicon Harmony-M, Digitech VR, Samson Q7, Sennheiser E855, Custom Console, and lots of other silly stuff!

K+E=W (Knowledge Plus Experience = Wisdom.)