Mainstage is not a superset of Gig Performer. There are some things it does that we don't and there are many things we do that it doesn't! Lighter CPU utilization along with features like predictive loading that allows you to use more plugins than would normally fit in memory are just a couple of examples. Multi-instance support is another cool feature that opens many doors. Full bidirectional remote control via OSC means you don't even need to have access to your laptop during a show
I would note that if our claims were not true, people would not spend $149 on Gig Performer when they could just buy MS for $30.
You're absolutely correct that Gig Performer requires more initial set up but so what? Unless you're a mix engineer, the visual approach to creating and connecting plugins together is easier for most people to understand than the channel strip model, much easier to see exactly what is going on.
More importantly, Gig Performer is not about instant gratification. We're trying to provide a deep and solid solution for professional players. Based on knowing who are some of our users (who paid for it, not people who endorse in return for free copies), I'm pretty comfortable that we're on the right path. GP is being used by keyboard players, guitarists, singers and by FOH sound engineers who use it for mixer effects, controlling it from the back of the room with an ipad OSC client.
Are we perfect? Nope! Are we striving for perfection? Absolutely!
I would encourage people to download the trial version, which will run fully functional for two weeks and see for themselves. I would also encourage people to browse our own forums and ask questions to our community.
[quote=Bachus]Mainstage does everything Gig performer does and more/quote]
I think Gigperformer is definately on the right track, for a young program its absolutely incredible.. reports are its rockstable.. and like a said.. it offers most of the things mainstage does, and like you said some things that mainstage does not..
Yet currently, i stick to mainstage at its lower price and including all logic instruments on Mac (altough most of them never used because of my VST collection, but Alchemy is still one of my favorites), makes it hard to beat, espescially since i been using it for quite some time now and know most ins and outs..
If i was however on Windows, i would definately be on Gigperformer.... altough, i am currently also enjoying reason.. and seeing possibilities to use this as both daw and keyboard host, there are also options for preloading patches...
Looking forward to further development of Gigperformer, wondering if there is a list of features planned for the future?