|
|
|
|
|
|
#251095 - 12/16/08 07:43 PM
Re: some Korg PA 800 OS2.0 recordings
|
Senior Member
Registered: 09/21/00
Posts: 43703
|
Originally posted by Diki: Sorry, guys. Wasn't trying to take it the wrong way...
It's just that Zuki has been the MOST ardent fanboy of the PA800 since the day he got it, works 25/8 on it, and has yet to illustrate a single point he has made with any music. Now, don't get me wrong, but if you have a work schedule THAT deep, for one thing, shyness can't be a factor And professionalism is pretty much a given.
So why post on thread after thread after thread about how great the PA800 is, without so much as ONE demo? I'm not looking to chop the guy down, I'd simply like some kind of reference to what he is saying... Talking about music is like dancing about mathematics - it doesn't convey anything substantive. It's ALL opinion without illustration. And I'm sorry, but everyones' opinion has EXACTLY the same weight (just about zero) without some kind of demonstration of it's position.
To me, something might be the best sounding thing in the world. To you, it might sound like a kazoo Unless I post something in audio form, how do you decide whether (in YOUR opinion) I'm right or wrong? By grammar? Or writing style?
Or how many emoticons I use? I can't believe I'm agreeing Totally with Diki.... but on this post....,spot on !!
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#251100 - 12/17/08 05:28 AM
Re: some Korg PA 800 OS2.0 recordings
|
Senior Member
Registered: 11/16/05
Posts: 1107
Loc: Sydney, NSW, Australia
|
Chas,
fair call, i may be being harsh on Donny.
no one likes to hear negative feedback on a performance, i am happy for it to comemy way but please be civil about it.
To be honest i was pretty proud of what i made on the PA800 and i was hoping for more positive feedback from other peeple.(i dont want to sound cocky) but at the same time i thank the people who have responded, i much appreciate it.
having owned a lot of keyboards of different brands i really beleive the Korg sound is a live punchy sound. i prefer it over Yamaha personally and to my ears it sounds great! its definitely the sound i have been looking for in all the keyboards i have previously owned.
another long story i dont want to dig up again but after all the crap that went on over the past few weeks i have completely lost all credability for Donny's opinion and "knowledge" of keybaords and sound.
if anyone else said the drums sounded hollow or something then yeah great, ide get to work and try to improve as ide take their opnions into mind, but the fact that it came from Donny just really bothered me.
Of coarse some people are never going to like what they hear and i am sure there are more than just Donny. I have had about 77 downloads of the Canon piece so obviously people are holding their comments to themselves. this is natural i am not holding a gun to anyones head. im just saying, heres some work i have done, have a listen, if you like it great, if u dont, thats fine, u can tell me what your thinking but obviously keep it civil and within reason?
Maybe its just Donny's wording which made his comment sound more harsh, as I have always beleived, the internet is evil in this sense. it makes people sound more blunt and direct without showing facial punctuation and emotion.
Nick
_________________________
Yamaha PSR SX900 / Roland G70 / Roland BK9 / Korg PA700 / Roland GW-8L / Roland Fantom O6
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#251101 - 12/17/08 07:06 AM
Re: some Korg PA 800 OS2.0 recordings
|
Senior Member
Registered: 09/29/05
Posts: 6703
Loc: Roswell,GA/USA
|
Originally posted by Nick G:
no one likes to hear negative feedback on a performance Depends on what your motives are when you post. I occasionally send Diki something for what I know will be an honest assessment. It usually has something to do with a (synth) voice or harmonizer use or recording technique, but they're always something I respect his knowledge about; AND I know I'll get an honest answer. For instance, I can tell you that he is no fan of Korg saxes (or pianos) but does really like Yammy guitars. That's okay. I personally liked the Korg sax but when he pointed out the how Korg was unable to articulate the sax voice in an authentic way, I learned something valuable and even tried harder to adjust my playing technique to accommodate this deficiency. Perhaps this is the way you should treat what you view as 'negative' criticism. Since nothing is perfect, there is always something to criticize. To be honest i was pretty proud of what i made on the PA800 and i was hoping for more positive feedback [/B] Big mistake. I'd change that to "hoping for more OBJECTIVE feedback". Having everyone agree with your assessment of your own work has zero value. another long story i dont want to dig up again but after all the crap that went on over the past few weeks i have completely lost all credibility for Donny's opinion and "knowledge" of keyboards and sound. [/B] Don't mistake Donny's buying habits with a lack of knowledge about keyboards. He's probably had more real-life experience with a wider variety of keyboards, especially arranger keyboards, than anyone on this board. His habit of 'praising, then trading' may be annoying, but it would be a stretch to say that he has no credibility. He is, after all, one of the few full-time working pro's on this board with many years of experience. Of coarse some people are never going to like what they hear [/B] ....and that's something to keep in mind when analyzing their feedback. If you think that a response is from this type of person, chuck it and move on to the next one. If Monk had listened to all the criticism of his playing, we'd probably never have experienced the haunting beauty of 'round midnight. Keep on posting. chas
_________________________
"Faith means not wanting to know what is true." [Nietzsche]
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#251104 - 12/17/08 03:14 PM
Re: some Korg PA 800 OS2.0 recordings
|
Senior Member
Registered: 11/16/05
Posts: 1107
Loc: Sydney, NSW, Australia
|
Originally posted by leeboy: Nick, Nice work..I enjoyed them both.. By the way which PA1 style did you start with..on the trance? I have a PA2 , but also have all of the PA1 styles. I really like the style you came up with for the trance.
Thanks, Lee Lee and Harold - thanks for the feedback. much appreciated! Lee - to be honest now i cant remember where i got that style from. all i know its called "Dream" and i was pretty sure it came from a PA80 or PA1x style set. But like I mentioned i did a bit of editing and had to swap drum kits to get that nice punchy sound. Of all keyboards i have ever owned, this is definitely my most favorite dance/trance style yet! it just works with everything... Squeak - the build quality of the PA 800 is pretty good. the fact that its plastic obviously makes it 'weaker' than a metal keyboard liek the motif, but it still seems very sturdy and well put together. i remember the tyros 2 and the psr3000, u could literally twist the keyboard with your bare hands and u would hear it creak. this does not happen with the PA, its a much more firmer build... the buttons feel just as good as the Motif did, the sliders are also very good. they are a little but smaller than the motif sliders but still nice n sturdy. i remember playing on an MM6 or a Juno D(i think it was Juno D or G) and those sliders felt like toys. As i have said before i think the PA 800 is ugly as but it is still a well built keyboard... the onboard speakers are surprisingly alot better than i expected too. I run my PA 800 through a Logitech Z3200 THX speaker setup and they really bring the keyboard alive! I will be posting some more demos soon. after owning a Motif synth for so long, going back to an arranger is a learning curve again. i basically need to re learn most of the chords for the songs i use to play as well as all the style changes, fills, track mutes, un mutes etc etc. Nick
_________________________
Yamaha PSR SX900 / Roland G70 / Roland BK9 / Korg PA700 / Roland GW-8L / Roland Fantom O6
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|